Skip to main content

ICML

Institute for Constitutional Military Law

Reading Room Archive

Issues

Post-deployment health

6 records in this collection bear on it

The Constitution gives Congress the power to raise and regulate the armed forces, and the power to declare war. The executive has been sending troops to fight wars Congress has not declared, and then treating them outside the rules Congress did set. Section 1074f is one of those rules. It is ignored.

What Congress required

Congress required the services to record a service member’s health before a deployment, to assess it on return — physical and mental — and to keep the record. That has been the law since 1997.

It is a small statute and an unglamorous one. Its importance is not in what it says. It is in what follows when it is not done.

What happens when it is not done

A service member comes home injured and is not assessed. The injury goes undiagnosed and untreated. It surfaces as behavior: drinking, absence, insubordination, drugs. The command sees misconduct and separates the member administratively — no charge, no trial, and a characterization that follows them for life.

Years later that veteran stands in front of a board and is asked to show that the conduct which ended their service was the injury they brought home. The evidence that would have shown it is the assessment that was never made.

The government had a statutory duty to find the injury. It did not look. Then it punished the person for the symptoms, and later required them to prove a connection using a record the government itself failed to create. That is not a medical problem. It is the government benefiting from its own omission.

The two doors not taken

Congress built two protected ways to end the service of someone who is injured or who is accused of an offense. If they are injured, the law provides for medical retirement. If they have committed a crime, the Uniform Code provides for trial. Both are procedures. Both produce a record. Both can be reviewed. Congress also lets the Secretary discharge a member early (10 U.S.C. § 1169), but it never authorized the Secretary to brand that discharge with a judgment of the member’s service.

The administrative discharge is neither. It is the back door. It requires no finding of disability and no finding of guilt, and the person is branded on the way out.

That is the convenience of it. Once the useful service has been taken and the person comes back injured, the protected routes mean retiring them or trying them. Both are slow and both create an obligation. Shuttling them out the back costs the institution nothing.

The same back door is described, in its general form, at discharge and characterization of service.

Why the assessment fails even when it is given

Institutional inertia. The military does not want to change, and when a requirement is placed on it, it fights the requirement and then builds around it a procedure that insulates the institution from accountability.

The reason is not mysterious. The military exists to fight wars. Caring for the people who fight them is a thing commanders speak about and do not do — least of all in the infantry, in the Marine Corps and in the Army, where the culture is least forgiving of a man who says he is hurt.

That is the explanation for forms that make no sense on their face. A service member who has been away a year is asked, in the days before he flies home, whether he would like to be referred for care now. He says no. He was always going to say no. The form records that he declined.

And the record is then complete. The statute has been satisfied on paper, the assessment has been logged, and nothing has happened. That is not an accident of design. It is the design.

Why this is constitutional, not medical

Article I gives Congress the power to make rules for the government and regulation of the land and naval forces, and the power to declare war. Both are Congress’s. Neither is the executive’s.

What has happened is that the executive sends troops to fight in wars Congress has not declared, treats them beyond any rule Congress has laid down, and ignores the rules Congress did lay down — section 1074f among them. In their place it has created punishments Congress never authorized.

The result is constitutional violation at scale: liberty and privilege interests taken from tens of thousands of service members accused of some form of minor misconduct — much of it directly attributable to their overseas service and to psychiatric injury, and most of it occurring after the military’s failure to provide basic post-combat medical care.

What Congress should do

Congress has already legislated here once. The question is not whether it has the power. It is whether it will enforce what it has already required, and account for what was done in the years it was not enforced.

The Constitution needs Congress to step up. People are dying.

Where to go from here

What was done instead

The executive record

The departments’ own instruments on this issue, and the studies the services made of their own system, oldest first.

The rules a board must apply

Controlling authority

What binds a discharge review or records correction board deciding a case today.

The whole of the law →