Skip to main content

ICML

Institute for Constitutional Military Law

Reading Room Archive

Wall of Heroes

Barbara Baum

U.S. Marine Corps, 1985–1990

Barbara Baum as a Marine recruit, smiling in uniform and cap in front of an American flag, with a name tag reading BAUM.
Baum at boot camp, 1985. The Charlotte Observer, March 5, 1989, p. 1A.

Barbara Baum enlisted in the Marine Corps at twenty and became a military policewoman. She graduated with honors from military police school and from corrections school. In 1988 the Corps court-martialed her in its purge of women at Parris Island, broke her to private and locked her in the brig. She fought the conviction for two years. A military appeals court threw it out because two members of her court-martial panel were biased, and the Marine Corps dropped every charge and gave her an honorable discharge.

The recruit

Baum grew up in Mishawaka, Indiana, near South Bend. She enlisted in March 1985 and marched into Parris Island that May, the only boot camp for women in the Marine Corps. She wanted to be part of the elite corps, and she felt honored to be admitted. She had a steady hand with her M16 and could run faster and farther than other Marines.

The purge

In the fall of 1987 the Naval Investigative Service opened an investigation of lesbianism at Parris Island. It grew out of a single complaint, a male Marine’s report that his girlfriend was having sex with a military policewoman. The policewoman was Baum. Within a year about one in ten of the women who served as drill instructors there had been discharged or imprisoned.

Baum was the first of the women charged, in March 1988, with sodomy, indecent acts and obstruction of justice. The other woman involved was given immunity to testify against her. Baum faced a possible thirty-five years.

“The prosecutor asked for a stiff prison sentence to send a message ‘that as a Marine of any rank, such conduct will not be tolerated.’”The Charlotte Observer, March 5, 1989

In June 1988 she was convicted and sentenced to a year in the brig at Quantico, reduction to private, forfeiture of all pay and a dishonorable discharge. After her conviction, investigators questioned her for fourteen hours about other women. Her lawyers said the Marine Corps then backed away from the clemency her cooperation had been meant to earn. She was released in December 1988, after 226 days, and her dishonorable discharge was cut to a bad conduct discharge.

The court-martial knew who it was sentencing. Baum testified that she had been sexually abused as a child, by her brother and his friends and once by an uncle. She began drinking at thirteen, she later said, to forget it. The memories still tormented her.

What it cost her

She moved to Tampa, where she knew no one, and took a job sanding and painting bumpers in a car repair shop. Her defense had left her owing $14,000 to her first lawyer.

“They destroyed me. Nobody deserved this, least of all jail. Sure, people may look down on you if you’re a lesbian, but they never put you in jail.”Barbara Baum, to The Charlotte Observer, March 5, 1989

“I was served as an example.”Barbara Baum, to The Charlotte Observer, March 5, 1989

She still would not turn her back on the country.

“I feel jilted by the government. But if there was a time of crisis, a desperate attempt to get people to join, I would be one of the first.”Barbara Baum, to The Charlotte Observer, March 5, 1989

The appeal

The Washington law firm of Arnold & Porter took her case without a fee. On February 15, 1990, the Navy-Marine Corps Court of Military Review set aside her conviction and sentence. One member of her court-martial panel had attended her pretrial investigation and listened to the government’s main witness. Another had discussed the Parris Island investigation with a Navy investigator before the trial.

“Colonel Nunnally appears to have extrajudicial knowledge of the evidence and an interest in the outcome of the litigation.”Navy-Marine Corps Court of Military Review, United States v. Baum, 30 M.J. 626 (1990), as quoted by The New York Times, February 19, 1990

Eleven days later the commanding general at Parris Island, Maj. Gen. J.D. Lynch Jr., announced that it was “impracticable to conduct further proceedings against” her. He dropped every charge and agreed to give her an honorable discharge as a corporal, with back pay. He gave as his reasons the time that had passed and the cost of a new trial. Her lawyer called it a total victory. She was never tried again.

“I knew it was unfair from the start and I’d said all along it wasn’t all over.”Barbara Baum, to The New York Times, February 1990

Speaking out

She kept telling her story, so that others would know what was being done to women in the services.

“They want women out and this is an easy way to do it.”Barbara Baum, to The New York Times, April 10, 1990

In 1993, as Congress debated the military’s ban, she stood with other veterans to put a human face on it.

“I never harmed anybody.”Barbara Baum, to The Washington Blade, April 16, 1993

Why she is on this wall

Barbara Baum was an honor graduate the Marine Corps chose to make an example of. She had survived sexual abuse as a child, and she told her court-martial so. A survivor of that kind of harm deserved understanding and leniency. The Corps compounded it instead. It sent her to the brig, pressed her for names, and backed away from the leniency her cooperation was supposed to earn. She did not accept it. She took her case to the appeals court and won, because the men who judged her were not impartial. The Marine Corps never tried her again. It gave her the honorable discharge she had earned from the start.

Sources

Every story below is in the Archive, with its headline as printed, the passages quoted and a link to the clipping.