News ArticleCommentary
The Pittsburgh Courier – Saturday, October 20, 1945
The Courier opens its investigation into the Army’s blue discharge — neither honorable nor dishonorable, issued without trial, and falling hardest on Black soldiers. First of eight issues in this collection tracking the campaign to its result.
- Date
- 20 October 1945
- Publication
- The Pittsburgh Courier
- Collection
- Press Coverage

Front-page headline: Courier Launches Probe of Army’s Blue Discharges.
Passages
The Army and the Veterans Administration are dealing two separate, but equally as un-American and unauthoritative blows to the future of over two hundred thousand helpless Negro and white veterans who are holders of the blue discharge.
John H. Young III’s opening line, naming both targets of the campaign: the Army that issued the blue discharge and the VA that denied benefits on it.
Do not accept the Blue Discharge as a quick means of getting out of the Army. You will be losing Army benefits and benefits under the GI Bill of Rights. Do not accept a Blue Discharge unless you have had a hearing before a formal board.
A boxed notice to soldiers still in service, citing their right to a board hearing under AR 615-368 and 615-369.
The viciousness of the blue discharge as far as Negroes and the Army are concerned, is that too often it is the faucet to the wells of prejudice in the Army’s pattern of segregation.
The paper’s charge that the discharge was a channel for racial prejudice in a segregated Army.
Read the full text
Transcribed by the Institute from the scan above, including the text continued on an inside page. Words broken at the end of a line are rejoined; spelling, capitalization and punctuation are as printed, misprints included. A reading followed by [?] is uncertain in the scan.
Courier Launches Probe of Army’s Blue Discharges
Veteran Benefits Denied Holders
WASHINGTON — The Army and the Veterans Administration are dealing two separate, but equally as un-American and unauthoritative blows to the future of over two hundred thousand helpless Negro and white veterans who are holders of the blue discharge. This was revealed here last week when increasing comment by leading individuals and organizations demanded that The Courier launch an investigation to clarify the situation.
Charges are flying thick and fast on the Army’s handling of the issuance of the blue ticket which deprives holders of practically all benefits in compensation for military services. The Army is reportedly: (1) handing out the blue ticket with reckless abandon: (2) allowing the discharge to be issued without holding board hearings; (3) allowing commanding officers to use it as a weapon to settle personal differences with their men; (4) allowing prejudiced white officers to use it as a means of punishing Negro soldiers who do not like specifically, unbearable conditions growing out of the Army’s doctrine of white supremacy, and (5) issuing the blue discharge to Negroes in proportionately higher numbers than white dischargees.
CRITICISES REGULATIONS
Basic criticism of the blue discharge is that it is administered, under the authority of two loosely-drawn Army regulations (AR 615-368 and AR 615-369). These regulations set forward as reasons for discharge under the blue certificate, debatable issues that run all the way from “Habits or traits of character which serve to render his retention in the service undesirable” to the highly questionable charge of “enuresis” (bed wetting).
Inaptness and homo-sexuality are also reasons for discharge under the blue certificate.
An examination of those falling under these reasons shows that the “unfortunates” of the Nation, as well as the Army, are the ones who are being preyed upon by the blue discharge. Enlightened public opinion contends that most of these reasons are traceable to the responsibility of society rather than the individual and it cannot understand why the Army chooses to penalize these “unfortunates” who seem most in need of Army benefits and the opportunity to become better citizens under the educational provisions of the GI Bill of Rights. Too, the charge is that with all its medical facilities, the Army should have been able to separate these men and refuse to enlist them for duty: that the Army is penalizing men for a responsibility which was the Army’s in the first place.
COLORED GI’S VICTIMIZED
The viciousness of the blue discharge as far as Negroes and the Army are concerned, is that too often it is the faucet to the wells of prejudice in the Army’s pattern of segregation. There is evidence that prejudiced officers are interpreting bona-fide resentment to racist treatment as being indicative of possession of “traits of character which serve to render his retention in the service undesirable.” These officers invoke such intolerable situations on Negro soldiers that some of them willingly accept the blue discharges to get out of the Army as soon as possible.
One story comming from a Congressman’s office in Chicago is that some fifty Negro soldiers near Chicago were blandly asked if they wanted a discharge. When they answered in the affirmative, they were invited in to sign. Not until they were actually in the act of signing did they discover that they were signing for blue discharges. The charge here is that Negro soldiers are being tempted with the blue discharge as the quickest way to get out of the Army.
A high ranking officer whose present work is with the blue discharge believes that Army conditions, in some instances, are so intolerable, that men are feigning enuresis and homo-sexuality just to get out the Army. These men lose their rights by receiving the blue discharge.
There is no question as to the veracity of many of these charges of irregularities surrounding the Army’s issuance of the blue dis-
(Continued on Page 4 [?], Column 4 [?])
COURIER EXPOSES USE OF ARMY’S BLUE DISCHARGES
(Continued From Page 1)
charge. Many of these charges have been substantiated by the Discharge Board of Review, appointed by the Secretary of War. Since this board began hearings a short time ago over 30 per cent of the cases involving blue discharges have been settled in favor of revoking it and issuing the honorable (white) certificate.
V. A. GUILTY OF WITCH-HUNT
As open to question as the Army’s issuance of the blue discharge, is the Veterans Administration’s use of a power which Congress never intended to be granted that agency in carrying out the provisions of the GI Bill. The V. A. has decided that its local or regional officers have the right to examine each holder of the blue discharge to determine whether or not he is entitled to benefits under the GI Bill.
Section 1305 of the GI Bill clearly states: “A discharge or release from active service under conditions other than dishonorable shall be a prerequisite to entitlement to veterans’ benefits.”
Upon reading this section, the V. A. immediately [?] embarks on a witch-hunt to interpret what Congress meant by “conditions other than dishonorable.” Although it is clear to many authorities on legal interpretation that Congress meant only to exclude those holding a dishonorable discharge, the V. A. comes up with the fantastic deduction that although the blue discharge is not a dishonorable one, the “conditions” under which the blue discharge is issued may be interpreted as being dishonorable. Through this hodge-podge of logic the V. A. asserts that Congress gave [?] it power to say whether or not the holder of the blue discharge should receive benefits under the GI Bill—this, despite the fact that Congress sets forth, in clear and unmistakable language, the list of those to be excluded.
Section 300 of the GI Bill states:
“The discharge or dismissal by reason of the sentence of a general court-martial or any person from the military or naval forces, or the discharge of any such person on the ground that he was a conscientious objector who refused to perform military duty or refused to wear the uniform or otherwise to comply with lawful orders of competent military authority, or as a deserter, or of an officer by the acceptance of his resignation for the good of the service, shall bar all rights of such person . . . under any laws administered by the Veterans Administration.
This section makes it clear that Congress intended to bar from rights under the GI Bill only those who had been dishonorably discharged as a result of general court-martial. The exceptions, Congress was careful to list as being a conscientious objector and an officer resigning for the good of the service.
(That there is uncertainty and confusion on the loose interpretation adopted by the V. A. is demonstrated by the fact that a member of the Public Relations staff of V. A. told this correspondent last week that there was no question but that a blue discharge entitled the holder to all rights under the GI Bill. He later retracted this view after talking with the Solicitor’s office of V. A.)
MENACE TO NEGRO VETERANS IN SOUTH
This usurpation of a right never intended by Congress, gives the regional and local officers of V. A. the right to rule over the holder of a blue discharge, regardless of that officer’s judgment to determine what constitutes honorable and dishonorable “conditions.” No written instructions have gone out from V. A. and the entire system is open to question since the judgment to be exercised has taken no concrete form. Needless to say, many holders of the blue discharge will be subject to the whims and prejudices of local officers of V. A. To the Negro in the South, holding a blue discharge, this constitutes a menace of serious proportions.
In attempting to clear up the muddle of the blue discharge, the Secretary of War has appointed a Discharge [?] Review Board to which holders [?] of the blue discharge may appeal [?]. Although this board has a [?] record for fairness, it is felt that creation of the board does not come close to solving the prooblem.
HEARINGS HELD ONLY IN WASHINGTON
Main criticism is that the board holds hearings in Washington. A holder of the blue discharge, living in California, must either trust someone here to represent him, or take the long and expensive trip to Washington. Neither of these alternatives would appear to be conclusive to the best interests of the person seeking appeal. Many veterans may fail to appeal simply because they do not have the money with which to make the trip.
If a person seeking appeal is not present, the board can only rule on the evidence that is presented by his representative in affidavit form. Quite often, some valuable evidence has been left out and the fact that the indidividual is not present mitigates against his receiving full benefit of his evidenee.
The board is divided into two panels with a Negro member serving on each one. Col. West Hamilton is on panel No. 1 and Col Chauncey Hooper on panel No. 2.
As this is being written, the Army continues to issue the questionable blue discharge and the V. A. still insists that it has a right to rule on the eligibility of veterans holding it.
Warning: All Soldiers!
Do not accept the Blue Discharge as a quick means of getting out of the Army. You will be losing Army benefits and benefits under the GI Bill of Rights. Do not accept a Blue Discharge unless you have had a hearing before a formal board. You are entitled to a hearing under Army Regulations 615-368 and 615-369. All hearings must include sworn witnesses. The rules of procedure and evidence must be carried out to the letter.
Blue Discharge Holders
(Take These Steps If Denied Benefits Under GI Bill of Rights)
- Appeal to Solicitor’s Office, Veteran’s Administration, Washington, D. C.
- If the Solicitor’s decision is not satisfactory, appeal to the Administrator, General Omar Bradley, Veteran’s Administration, Washington, D. C.
- If the Administrator’s decision is not satisfactory, appeal to President Harry S. Truman, the White House, Washington, D. C.
Cite this record
The Pittsburgh Courier – Saturday, October 20, 1945. Press Coverage, Institute for Constitutional Military Law, https://icml.us/coverage/the-pittsburgh-courier-saturday-october-20-1945/