Skip to main content

ICML

Institute for Constitutional Military Law

Reading Room Archive

News ArticleCommentary

The Pittsburgh Courier – Saturday, February 9, 1946

The end of the campaign, as the House committee acts and asks that the certificates be reviewed. Eight issues from the Courier launching its probe to Congress moving — the clearest record in this collection of press pressure changing discharge policy.

Date
9 February 1946
Publication
The Pittsburgh Courier
Collection
Press Coverage

Download the document (PDF)

The Pittsburgh Courier – Saturday, February 9, 1946

Front-page headline: Courier Campaign Gets Results, House Committee Acts, Asks to Review Certificates.

Passages

Revolutionary changes in the Army’s entire system of releasing servicemen appeared probable here last week as the result of The Pittsburgh Courier’s relentless fight against the insidious “blue” discharges, when the House Military Affairs Committee urged the Army to review every blue discharge issued since the start of the war.

Notable quotationp. 1

The campaign’s result, sixteen weeks after it began.

The whole practice of affixing moral labels on individuals by the Army is a survival of obsolete conceptions.

Notable quotationpp. 1, 4

From the report of Representative Carl T. Durham’s special committee of the House Military Affairs Committee, as quoted by the Courier.

Nothing could more clearly prove the anomalous and illogical and disingenuous nature of the blue discharge than this policy of the Veterans’ Administration.

Notable quotationp. 4

The report, on the VA’s practice of denying GI Bill benefits to blue-discharge holders.

The Veterans Administration should be stopped from passing moral verdicts on the history of any soldier, and should be required to accept all veterans but those expressly excluded by Congress in Section 300 Public Law No. 346, and any others who in its judgment should be excluded.

Notable quotationp. 4

The committee’s call for legislation. Public Law No. 346 is the Servicemen’s Readjustment Act of 1944, the GI Bill.

Read the full text848 words, transcribed from the scan

Transcribed by the Institute from the scan above, including the text continued on an inside page. Words broken at the end of a line are rejoined; spelling, capitalization and punctuation are as printed, misprints included. A reading followed by [?] is uncertain in the scan.

Congress Raps ‘Blue Discharges’

Courier Campaign Gets Results; House Committee Acts; Asks Army To Review Certificates

Charges “Squeeze Play” on Veterans; Suggests New Types of Discharges

WASHINGTON — Revolutionary changes in the Army’s entire system of releasing servicemen appeared probable here last week as the result of The Pittsburgh Courier’s relentless fight against the insidious “blue” discharges, when the House Military Affairs Committee urged the Army to review every blue discharge issued since the start of the war.

In addition, the House Committee pointed out that an investigation had convinced them that blue discharges were “offensive, illogical and unfair,” terms frequently used in The Courier’s crusading articles against this grave menace to Army veterans.

RECOMMEND NEW SETUP

The entire philosophy of the present Army discharge system appeared to be tottering when the House Committee suggested that the Army give the following four kinds of discharges:

  1. Honorable.
  2. “Discharges under honorable conditions” for indaptability, inaptness and physical disability resulting from misconduct.
  3. “General discharges” based on judgment of a special court-martial or board comparable to a special court-martial for continuous misconduct, fraudulent enlistment and similar offenses.
  4. “Dishonorable discharge” as a result of a court-martial.

ONE-THIRD ALREADY CHANGED

Many instances have already been reported wherein veterans holding blue discharges have been unable to get employment, even though one-third of all the “blues” issued have been replaced with honorable discharges.

In other cases the Veterans Administration has refused veterans with blue discharges the full benefits under the GI Bill of Rights.

“MORAL LABELS” CONDEMNED

The report, made to Congress by Rep. Carl T. Durham (D., N. C.), chairman of a special committee of the House Military Affairs Committee, contained language and content fully contiguous with The Courier’s articles on the blue discharges. It was another evidence of the indisputable power of the

(Continued on Page 4, Column 1)

Congress Committee Raps ‘Blue Discharges’

(Continued from Page 1)

Negro press and of its influence with the Nation’s law makers.

The findings, which carried the weight of opinion of the entire committee, calls for the specific abolishment of the blue discharge. The document strongly [?] urged the abolition of all discharges as they are now known.

It was charged that there was great question as to whether the Army had the right to affix moral labels on individuals.

“The whole practice of affixing moral labels on individuals by the Army is a survival of obsolete conceptions. There is no reason why all separations from the service other than those of men convicted of serious offenses by judicial processes should not be regarded as essentially honorable, though it is not necessary for them to be so designated. The cases considered under the blue discharge system are, essentially, discharges for administrative reasons in the interests of greater efficiency in the service. The Army should not attempt moral labels,” the report said.

VETS ADMINISTRATION SCORED

On veterans’ benefits (holders of the blue discharges are denied benefits under the GI Bill of Rights), the committee report ripped the Veterans Administration wide open for its handling of holders of the blue discharge. It charged the VA with making an interpretation which amounted to assumption of powers never intended by Congress.

Veterans Administration has held that that portion of the GI Bill which says that benefits shall go to those discharged “under conditions other than dishonorable,” was not inclusive of all holders of the blue discharge. The House report throughly discounted this VA theory and declared:

“It would appear from the very awkardness of the language employed, the phrase ‘under conditions other than dishonorable’ instead of the more natural phrase ‘an honorable discharge,’ that Congress was generously providing the benefits on as broad a base as possible and intended that all persons not actually given a dishonorable discharge should profit by this generosity.”

WANTS LEGISLATION AGAINST VA

“Nothing could more clearly prove the anomalous and illogical and disingenuous nature of the blue discharge than this policy of the Veterans’ Administration.”

Soundly slapping the VA, the report called for legislation which would end its usurped power of sitting as a jury. In strong language the committee declared:

“The Veterans Administration should be stopped from passing moral verdicts on the history of any soldier, and should be required to accept all veterans but those expressly excluded by Congress in Section 300 Public Law No. 346, and any others who in its judgment should be excluded.”

VETS GET SQUEEZE PLAY

Bumping VA and Army heads together, the committee further contended:

“The present arrangement for holders of the blue discharge constitutes a ‘squeeze play’ between the War Department and the Veterans Administration.”

Brig. Gen. John L. Pierce of the War Department Discharge Review Board, said that although examination of all blue discharges would be automatic, veterans who hold them can apply for a personal hearing before the boards located here and in Puerto Rico.

COURIER LAUNCHED FIGHT

The Courier first brought the attention of the Nation to the blue discharge in a series of articles last November. Congressional interest developed when Sen. Edwin C. Johnson (D., Col.), read The Courier articles into the Congressional record last November 8.

Cite this record

The Pittsburgh Courier – Saturday, February 9, 1946. Press Coverage, Institute for Constitutional Military Law, https://icml.us/coverage/the-pittsburgh-courier-saturday-february-9-1946/