Skip to main content

ICML

Institute for Constitutional Military Law

Reading Room Archive

News ArticleCommentary

‘Confessions’ Frequent in Military Investigations

Part 2 of 7. The case is often decided in the interrogation room. Landau documents pressure to confess, counsel delayed or denied, and investigations that feed courts-martial and discharge boards alike, with no investigator ever court-martialed for mistreating a suspect.

Date
11 September 1967
Author
Jack C. Landau
Publication
Staten Island Advance (Staten Island, N.Y.), p. 15
Collection
Press Coverage

See the page at Newspapers.com The series in the Congressional Record

Headline as published: ‘Confessions’ Frequent in Military Investigations
The headline as the Staten Island Advance printed it, shown for identification. Read the original

Passages

He receives the lifelong scar of a federal court conviction or less than honorable discharge in the police interrogation room without ever having reached a courtroom.

Notable quotationPart 2

On what follows a confession, since 70 per cent of Army court-martial suspects pleaded guilty, most of them on confessions.

The U.S. Court of Military Appeals reversed a total of 51 cases last year, 40% of them because of illegal investigations. The court’s opinions do not show a single case of a military investigator being court-martialed for mistreatment of a suspect.

Notable quotationPart 2

Accountability for the investigators.

But the average enlisted man is ignorant of his legal rights, isolated from his family and friends, and in general sincerely believes that the military will “give me a fair shake.”

Notable quotationPart 2

Landau on why confessions came so easily. Navy investigators in Norfolk reported that 90 per cent of their suspects confessed.

Cite this record

Jack C. Landau, “‘Confessions’ Frequent in Military Investigations,” Staten Island Advance (Staten Island, N.Y.), p. 15, 11 September 1967. Press Coverage, Institute for Constitutional Military Law, https://icml.us/coverage/confessions-frequent-in-military-investigations-1967/

This work belongs to its publisher. ICML links to it and quotes it briefly for research and commentary; it is not reproduced here. Rights holders may request removal.