Skip to main content

ICML

Institute for Constitutional Military Law

Reading Room Archive

The Institute

Bulletin

News and commentary from the Institute for Constitutional Military Law, including announcements, the progress of its investigations, and short analysis of the law and the boards.

FOIA request · October 28, 2026

Office of the Secretary of Defense: the missing versions of the enlisted separations rule

DoD Directive 1332.14, now an Instruction, has governed the administrative separation of enlisted members and the characterization of their service since 1959. The Institute has collected every version and change it could find in the Federal Register, the Code of Federal Regulations, the Defense Technical Information Center and the Department’s FOIA reading room. It asked for the rest, each as issued: the December 29, 1976 Directive that renamed the undesirable discharge, its two changes, any changes to the 1982 Directive before 1993, the second change to the 2008 Instruction, the third change to the 2014 Instruction, and the Department’s own record of every issuance since 1959.

FOIA request · October 19, 2026

Air Force: the 1996 Inspection Agency report on the homosexual conduct policy at Hickam Air Force Base

In 1996 the Air Force accused four airmen and an officer at Hickam Air Force Base of violating the homosexual conduct policy, on information from another airman under a pretrial agreement, and the four airmen were administratively discharged. The Air Force Inspection Agency then reported on how the policy had been applied. RAND describes and quotes that report, but it has never been published. The Institute asked for the report with its exhibits, the order that started the investigation, and any action taken on its findings.

FOIA request · October 19, 2026

Office of the Secretary of Defense: the enlisted separations instruction as issued in 2014

DoD Instruction 1332.14 governs the administrative separation of enlisted members and the characterization of their service. The Defense Department publishes only the current version, which folds in later changes. The Institute asked for the Instruction as signed and issued on January 27, 2014, and for each later change as issued, so that the Archive can show the text as it stood when it governed.

FOIA request · October 19, 2026

Air Force: the contract for the new review boards web portal

Federal award data show that the Air Force signed contract FA701425C0055, described as the “AFRBA WEB PORTAL,” on September 29, 2025. Officials told the Government Accountability Office that a new electronic reading room for review board decisions would launch by October 2026. The Institute asked for the contract with its statement of work and every modification, the solicitation and award records, the accepted deliverables, and the records that show whether this portal is the new reading room and when it goes live.

FOIA request · October 13, 2026

Defense Health Agency: did the military keep the founder’s own deployment health records and blood samples?

Congress required a blood sample and a medical examination for every servicemember coming home from a combat deployment, and required that the records be kept in a central location so they could be studied later. The Institute’s founder asked the Defense Health Agency for his own records from his return from Iraq in 2003, including his post-deployment health assessment and every serum sample on file. He put his own claim in writing. No blood was drawn when he came home, and no provider interviewed or examined him. The request asks the Department to produce the records if they show otherwise, and to say so in writing if they do not exist.

FOIA request · October 13, 2026

Defense Health Agency: the post-deployment health assessments of one Marine company home from Iraq in 2003

Every Marine coming home from Iraq in 2003 was supposed to be interviewed and examined by a health care provider, and the form recording it was supposed to be sent to a central military database. GAO never checked the Marine Corps. The Institute asked the Defense Health Agency for the post-deployment health assessments of Weapons Company, 3d Battalion, 7th Marines, with every name and identifier removed, and for a count of how many forms each provider certified on each day. The Institute’s founder served in that company and enclosed his own form. It shows a provider’s certification dated three days after he filled it out, and the line for the post-deployment blood sample is marked “N/A.”

FOIA request · October 13, 2026

Government Accountability Office: its 2003 review of post-deployment health assessments

The Government Accountability Office is part of Congress, so the Freedom of Information Act does not apply to it, but GAO releases its records under its own regulation. The Institute asked GAO for its copy of the Defense Department’s June 30, 2003 letter, the question GAO asked, the Department’s comments on GAO’s report, the work behind its finding that completed health assessments were not reviewed by a health care provider, and which services and units it reviewed.

FOIA request · October 13, 2026

Office of the Secretary of Defense: the 2003 letter that called post-deployment examinations “logistically impossible”

Congress requires a medical examination, including a mental health assessment, for every servicemember coming home from a combat or contingency deployment. In 2003 the Defense Department told the Government Accountability Office that complete physical examinations were “logistically impossible” and relied on a questionnaire instead. The Institute asked for that June 30, 2003 letter, the question it answered, the drafts behind it, and the Department’s comments on GAO’s report.

FOIA request · September 30, 2026

Office of the Secretary of Defense: the reading room and the federal website standards

Since 2018 federal law has required every agency to review its public websites, tell Congress which of them need modernizing and what that will cost, and report its progress every year. The Defense Department’s 2020 report to Congress listed its ten highest-traffic public websites. The reading room, where the military review boards publish their decisions, was not among them. The Institute asked the Department’s Chief Information Officer for that report in full, with its cost and schedule estimates, the list of websites the office reviewed, its later reports, and any registration or review of the reading room under the Department’s own rules for public websites.